How to write a peer review essay

Share via Email Reviewing is a good way to keep up with literature and sharpen your own writing, says Brian Lucey.

How to write a peer review essay

Spell checker and grammar checker - handy tools! Anything else you'd normally use when writing a project like the one you're critiquing. Perform a "Save As For example, if I get a document named Kirk-Trek. Creating a second version helps prevent the original author from saving over the original draft, just in case.

Turn on Track Changes in your text editor so the author can see your line-edits. Read through your partner's draft before you even start critiquing. You'll be surprised how many things which you don't understand the first time through that become clear during the second read.

Once you've read it through, write out the essay's thesis statement or come up with one if the author didn't make it clear. Mark up the text as you go along - with Track Changes turned on.

You'll return this document to the original author, in addition to your separate written critique. Make copyedit, formatting, and other markups in the manuscript itself. This helps the author improve the micro-writing and professional appearance, two things vital to success.

Use annotations or comments for larger suggestions, questions, and so forth - substantive recommendations on how to best improve the document.

Before you read and while you read the paper

Or save these larger comments for the critique document. Next, write out a full outline of the essay's main points skipping the introduction and conclusion. Now answer these questions: What do you see as the main topic or topics? That is, what do all the sentences and paragraphs have in common, subject-wise?

Is this the optimal structure to make this overall argument? Are all the parts directly related to that overall topic?

Does everything support the overall theme or thesis? What do you see as the main thesis? Do all the paragraphs compare, contrast, and come together to form the argument? Does this agree with the author's stated thesis? In what ways might the draft need to change so that its thesis and structure accurately reflect each other?on the peer review process, a defining fea-ture of scientific discourse that subjects the literature forming the foundation of cred- After this first pass, write the first two paragraphs of your review, which will sum-marize the research question addressed and the contribution of the work.

If the jour-. FResearch is an innovative open access publishing platform offering immediate publication, open peer review and full data deposition and sharing.

FPrime FWorkspace.

Revision: Conducting Peer Reviews

item: ${!topBarItem} search. file_uploadSubmit your research. search menu close.

how to write a peer review essay

search. Browse; Overall though, this is a timely and needed essay. It is . FResearch is an innovative open access publishing platform offering immediate publication, open peer review and full data deposition and sharing. FPrime FWorkspace.

how to write a peer review essay

item: ${!topBarItem} search. file_uploadSubmit your research. search menu close. search. Overall though, this is a timely and needed essay. It is well researched. Conducting Peer Reviews.

For further information see our handout on How to Proofread.. Before you read and while you read the paper. Find out what the writer is intending to do in the paper (purpose) and what the intended audience is.

Peer Review Read: Read the instructions for the Week 3 Personal Essay. Write: As part of the writing process, you are expected to reflect . Peer Review Sample Comments LANG Prof. Traywick More Useful Comments (specific, concrete, use examples) You started off with a wonderful title.

It is an attention grabber, and is a perfect explanation of Also I suggest getting a few more sources for your essay so it will give you more information to.

work with.

Peer Review - New York Essays